Le CPE est dans la poubelle!
Just got finished watching the 8 o’clock news w/ Mme, during which Villepin talked about the now-FINISHED CPE that he fought so hard for...
Earlier today Alex told me that the CPE was finally done with, that despite the earlier presidential “go-ahead, but reformulate,” the law that’s had everyone out in the streets for the past two months was officially canned. When I got home, Mme. asked if I’d “heard the news” and in response to my “Oui!” she explained that it wasn’t over yet... that this morning one of the kids had arrived late because protesters were swarming the tracks near Homme de Fer early this morning, after the announcement of the CPE’s final descent. Why? Because the fight, they claimed, wasn’t over... with raised eyebrows and a shaking head, Mme explained that they were now calling for the booting of Villepin from office, as well as the repeal of the CPE’s predecessor, the CNE (Contrat Nouvelle Embauche), which initially passed without the fuss that the CPE riled up.
“Ça n’arrête jamais!” (“It never stops!”) I exclaimed, with Mme.’s habitual “Non, mais attend... maintenant qu’ils ont ce qu’ils voulait, il faut arrêter... mais non...” (“No, but wait [which is a very Mme.-like expression]... now that they have what they wanted, they should stop... but no...”). And so we agreed to meet back up after dinner to check out what the news had to offer.
Before going in to the details revealed by the news, can I just say how impressed I am that, first, people of all ages actually follow politics and take to the streets when they don’t like what’s going on... second, that they stay in the streets and gain more support the longer the government holds out... and third, that they succeed in toppling the government’s initial plans, even when it looked like Villepin had all the big-wigs on his side. Some say France is afraid of change and doesn’t know how to accept what’s inevitable in order to continue on in the society. There may be some truth to this, as well as to the argument that they go somewhat overboard (like the continuation of protests even after they got what they were fighting for). But on the other hand, it is simply UNBELIEVABLE, in my American-trained mind, that the country’s people can come together like that and actually bring about governmental changes. Yes, things are different here, things are considerably more nationalised, and the country is a lot smaller than the grand ol’ US. But nonetheless, it’s been rather eye-opening to see things in action here and watch a different kind of politics unfold.
What struck me about tonight’s news report was Villepin’s appearance in the news studio, talking directly to the news reporter. Just them, at the desk, the Prime Minister talking to the news castor and not directly to the camera or to a huge crowd of people waiting for him to “perform” – as is often the case – a previously-prepared speech. It was the first time I’d heard Villepin actually defend himself “in person”, and you know, I was impressed (seems to be the sentiment of the evening). After reading all sorts of pamphlets and opinions against the man and his CPE agenda, after hearing hundreds of students chanting “Down with Villepin! Put him in jail!”... there he was, talking about his agenda, and the first thing that crossed my mind was the stark contrast between him and, say, Bush. Or so many other American politicians, that read their speeches, that reserve their emotions, that fill the air with vagueries and vascillate so as not to upset either side.
Given, I was listening to the report in French and probably didn’t catch all the nuances. But it was pretty obvious that Villepin is a man who knows how to talk. Who knows how to debate. There he was, with only a small slip of paper on the desk in front of him, facing the questions of a news castor, and, with intense eyes and an impassioned air, he explained why he’d come up with the CPE, what the problems were with the country’s 27% unemployment rate for those under 26, and that he would continue to work towards a solution even though his CPE has now been shot down. Yes, he could have been lying, yes he probably didn’t reveal his entire agenda, yes he talked over the newcastor a good amount of the time and didn’t answer some of the questions. But by god, he seemed to have a belief, he seemed to be passionate, and he certainly spoke damn well – naturally, that is, not in the manner of a formulated speech. As Mme. said, “When he talks, it sounds good... but it doesn’t work that easily.” Very true. The CPE was supposed to help insure the security of the youth by providing them with more jobs. Instead it became, as Villepin put it, the symbol of insecurity, of precarity. Because, while it did try to address a huge national problem, it wasn’t the right solution (not to say there is a “right” solution in all of this jumble).
I’ve definitely found myself laying some heavy critique on the U.S. after learning about various European policies, even though I know I’m not all that well-versed in either’s political agendas and can’t offer a truly informed opinions. Tonight’s “impression” was probably laced with some of this “Ah, the European way...” haze. But really, it’s been quite the experience living through all this, despite my naiveté. More and more I wonder just how the US manages to be a single country... while I’m certainly not a Bush fan, I can’t even imagine what the job of “President of the United States” even means. How does one go about making decisions that will influence millions of people throughout 50 wide-spread states? That’s just the problem... one CAN’T address all those millions at the same time. The US government definitely seems much farther away from its people than the French government and its republic... but it makes sense in terms of size and unity. Never could I imagine students marching in universities and high schools across the country and fomenting change on a national level after two months of striking. Our country’s just not built in such a way that that could happen. We’re just too goddamn big. And then, of course, there’s the whole values business, with capitalism leading the way, each to his own, and so on and so forth...
In any case, I couldn’t agree more that living abroad is that clichéd “eye-opening” experience. Text books and news reports, novels and films can only do so much to paint a picture of something fundamentally “different.” You don’t actually feel that difference until you’re steeping in it. And even if you don’t understand it, even if you don’t necessarily agree with it, it opens up doors into new ways of thinking and seeing that you never new existed. I never really identified with being “American” until coming here. And realizing just how much I HAVE been influenced by American life and mentality, as hodgepodge as it is.
I wouldn’t say my patriotism has suddenly taken off, nor that any anti-American sentiments have increased... but I can say that seeing the US from outside the fish bowl has certainly sparked a greater understanding of what it means to come from the sprawling American land of red, white, and blue (as opposed to the many smaller countries – France in
Earlier today Alex told me that the CPE was finally done with, that despite the earlier presidential “go-ahead, but reformulate,” the law that’s had everyone out in the streets for the past two months was officially canned. When I got home, Mme. asked if I’d “heard the news” and in response to my “Oui!” she explained that it wasn’t over yet... that this morning one of the kids had arrived late because protesters were swarming the tracks near Homme de Fer early this morning, after the announcement of the CPE’s final descent. Why? Because the fight, they claimed, wasn’t over... with raised eyebrows and a shaking head, Mme explained that they were now calling for the booting of Villepin from office, as well as the repeal of the CPE’s predecessor, the CNE (Contrat Nouvelle Embauche), which initially passed without the fuss that the CPE riled up.
“Ça n’arrête jamais!” (“It never stops!”) I exclaimed, with Mme.’s habitual “Non, mais attend... maintenant qu’ils ont ce qu’ils voulait, il faut arrêter... mais non...” (“No, but wait [which is a very Mme.-like expression]... now that they have what they wanted, they should stop... but no...”). And so we agreed to meet back up after dinner to check out what the news had to offer.
Before going in to the details revealed by the news, can I just say how impressed I am that, first, people of all ages actually follow politics and take to the streets when they don’t like what’s going on... second, that they stay in the streets and gain more support the longer the government holds out... and third, that they succeed in toppling the government’s initial plans, even when it looked like Villepin had all the big-wigs on his side. Some say France is afraid of change and doesn’t know how to accept what’s inevitable in order to continue on in the society. There may be some truth to this, as well as to the argument that they go somewhat overboard (like the continuation of protests even after they got what they were fighting for). But on the other hand, it is simply UNBELIEVABLE, in my American-trained mind, that the country’s people can come together like that and actually bring about governmental changes. Yes, things are different here, things are considerably more nationalised, and the country is a lot smaller than the grand ol’ US. But nonetheless, it’s been rather eye-opening to see things in action here and watch a different kind of politics unfold.
What struck me about tonight’s news report was Villepin’s appearance in the news studio, talking directly to the news reporter. Just them, at the desk, the Prime Minister talking to the news castor and not directly to the camera or to a huge crowd of people waiting for him to “perform” – as is often the case – a previously-prepared speech. It was the first time I’d heard Villepin actually defend himself “in person”, and you know, I was impressed (seems to be the sentiment of the evening). After reading all sorts of pamphlets and opinions against the man and his CPE agenda, after hearing hundreds of students chanting “Down with Villepin! Put him in jail!”... there he was, talking about his agenda, and the first thing that crossed my mind was the stark contrast between him and, say, Bush. Or so many other American politicians, that read their speeches, that reserve their emotions, that fill the air with vagueries and vascillate so as not to upset either side.
Given, I was listening to the report in French and probably didn’t catch all the nuances. But it was pretty obvious that Villepin is a man who knows how to talk. Who knows how to debate. There he was, with only a small slip of paper on the desk in front of him, facing the questions of a news castor, and, with intense eyes and an impassioned air, he explained why he’d come up with the CPE, what the problems were with the country’s 27% unemployment rate for those under 26, and that he would continue to work towards a solution even though his CPE has now been shot down. Yes, he could have been lying, yes he probably didn’t reveal his entire agenda, yes he talked over the newcastor a good amount of the time and didn’t answer some of the questions. But by god, he seemed to have a belief, he seemed to be passionate, and he certainly spoke damn well – naturally, that is, not in the manner of a formulated speech. As Mme. said, “When he talks, it sounds good... but it doesn’t work that easily.” Very true. The CPE was supposed to help insure the security of the youth by providing them with more jobs. Instead it became, as Villepin put it, the symbol of insecurity, of precarity. Because, while it did try to address a huge national problem, it wasn’t the right solution (not to say there is a “right” solution in all of this jumble).
I’ve definitely found myself laying some heavy critique on the U.S. after learning about various European policies, even though I know I’m not all that well-versed in either’s political agendas and can’t offer a truly informed opinions. Tonight’s “impression” was probably laced with some of this “Ah, the European way...” haze. But really, it’s been quite the experience living through all this, despite my naiveté. More and more I wonder just how the US manages to be a single country... while I’m certainly not a Bush fan, I can’t even imagine what the job of “President of the United States” even means. How does one go about making decisions that will influence millions of people throughout 50 wide-spread states? That’s just the problem... one CAN’T address all those millions at the same time. The US government definitely seems much farther away from its people than the French government and its republic... but it makes sense in terms of size and unity. Never could I imagine students marching in universities and high schools across the country and fomenting change on a national level after two months of striking. Our country’s just not built in such a way that that could happen. We’re just too goddamn big. And then, of course, there’s the whole values business, with capitalism leading the way, each to his own, and so on and so forth...
In any case, I couldn’t agree more that living abroad is that clichéd “eye-opening” experience. Text books and news reports, novels and films can only do so much to paint a picture of something fundamentally “different.” You don’t actually feel that difference until you’re steeping in it. And even if you don’t understand it, even if you don’t necessarily agree with it, it opens up doors into new ways of thinking and seeing that you never new existed. I never really identified with being “American” until coming here. And realizing just how much I HAVE been influenced by American life and mentality, as hodgepodge as it is.
I wouldn’t say my patriotism has suddenly taken off, nor that any anti-American sentiments have increased... but I can say that seeing the US from outside the fish bowl has certainly sparked a greater understanding of what it means to come from the sprawling American land of red, white, and blue (as opposed to the many smaller countries – France in